Sports Pundit Scoreboard

We track public sports picks from popular handicappers and compare them with final results. This is accountability research, not betting advice.

13Pundits tracked 888Picks logged 439Hits 399Misses

Just Resolved

866 decided picks · 50.7% hit rate
The Ice Guys · 2026-06-04
Unclear #NHL
Miss
my best bet for game two. there we go. my best bet. well i tried to get creative with the bargain bin special. give you something different. i m not giving you something different here. i m going back to the...
VS Result
Result: First-period total 1; line 1.5.
Picks & Parlays · 2026-06-03
Unclear #MLB
Miss
i can go under seven and a half
VS Result
Result: Game total 9; line 7.5.
Picks & Parlays · 2026-06-03
Unclear #MLB
Partial
give me the over 8
VS Result
Result: Game total 8; line 8.
PickDawgz · 2026-06-03
Total/Prop #NBA
Hit
i like the under 218 and a half
VS Result
Result: Game total 200; line 218.5.
PickDawgz · 2026-06-03
Aligned #NBA
Miss
i'm on the spurs here in this game one. i'll lay the four and a half
VS Result
Result: San Antonio Spurs margin -10; line -4.5.
Guy Boston Sports · 2026-06-03
Unclear #MLB
Hit
give me the red sox
VS Result
Result: Boston Red Sox margin 7.
Guy Boston Sports · 2026-06-03
Unclear #MLB
Miss
give me the nats
VS Result
Result: Washington Nationals margin -3.
Guy Boston Sports · 2026-06-03
Unclear #MLB
Hit
i like the a's
VS Result
Result: Athletics margin 1.

Scoreboard

Sorted by hit rate, with decided-pick volume as tie-breaker.

By Sport

Where the current pilot data is concentrated.

MLB

370
365 decided picks
55.6%Hit rate158Misses

NFL

119
119 decided picks
55.5%Hit rate50Misses

NBA

109
102 decided picks
49.0%Hit rate52Misses

Soccer

108
108 decided picks
60.2%Hit rate43Misses

Horse racing

102
92 decided picks
15.2%Hit rate57Misses

NHL

36
36 decided picks
58.3%Hit rate15Misses

NCAAF

32
32 decided picks
40.6%Hit rate19Misses

NCAAB

12
12 decided picks
58.3%Hit rate5Misses