#Materials / Mining · Pundit Scoreboard · Stock calls
10 calls
3 decided
2 hits
0 partial
1 misses
7 pending
🏆 The Scoreboard
⚡ Short <60 days
📈 Mid 60-360 days
🌳 Long >360 days
💡 Three time horizons: Short <60d · Mid 60-360d · Long >360d
💰 Avg P/L = equal-weight blind-follower model — average return per decided call
💸 Spectacular Misses
Sorted by loss magnitude. Up to 3 cards per pundit.
RIO SHORT
you can see a long slide for these names it goes on many runs but has not it keeps on having lower low it's generally had lower lows and especially lower highs
VS Reality
Miss: Entry $53.92 → Exit $78.92 · P/L -46.4% · vs SPY -67.3%
🎯 Spot-On Calls
Sorted by realized gain. Up to 3 per pundit.
MP LONG
I've always liked MP. It's just very recently people realized it's got great rare earth potential. Latinski's done a good job. It keeps losing money. That's un…
VS Reality
Bullseye: P/L +6187.0% · vs SPY +4103.0%
NUE LONG
That's Leon Talian. He's the chairman, president, CEO of Newor. This stock is at the right price.
VS Reality
Bullseye: Entry $117.00 → Exit $222.39 · P/L +90.1% · vs SPY +60.2%
🔮 Pending Verdicts
Bold calls whose horizon hasn't expired yet. Bullseye or miss?
MP LONG
2026 is going to be a great year for the rare earth segment.
VS Reality
Horizon: 2026-12-31 · 123 days remaining
FCX LONG
Freeport-McMoRan... this one looks pretty good. Cup base, 69.75 buy point. If you think the global economy isn't going to take too much of a hit, you understan…
VS Reality
Horizon: 2027-04-17 · 230 days remaining
MP LONG
Critical Metals... it's a spec... if you really want to be in that industry, you have to buy MP materials. They're for real.
VS Reality
Horizon: 2027-04-23 · 236 days remaining
NUE LONG
this is one of the longest owning stocks we have for the charitable trust... Nucor is just up on... blew me away... record quarterly shipment volumes... I thin…
VS Reality
Horizon: 2027-04-28 · 241 days remaining
MP LONG
I like it very much. It's the only one in that whole area I really bless because they got the government's back... and they have really good solid management.
VS Reality
Horizon: 2027-04-29 · 242 days remaining